Blog

April 16, 2025

Can You Sue the State for Wrongful Imprisonment? California Overview

Written by Pointer & Buelna, LLP. Lawyers For The People, reviewed by Adanté Pointer

If you or a loved one has been wrongfully convicted and imprisoned in California, you may wonder, can you sue the state for wrongful imprisonment? The short answer is yes—under specific legal conditions, individuals who have been unjustly incarcerated have the right to pursue compensation for the immense hardships they have faced. The emotional, financial, and psychological toll of wrongful imprisonment can be overwhelming, but legal avenues exist to help victims reclaim their lives. At Pointer and Buelna, LLP – Lawyers For The People, we are dedicated to fighting for those who have been unfairly punished by the justice system, ensuring they receive the compensation and justice they deserve.

What is Wrongful Imprisonment, and Can You Sue the State for It?

Wrongful imprisonment occurs when an individual is detained or incarcerated without legal justification. This can happen due to judicial errors, prosecutorial misconduct, false testimony, or ineffective legal representation. The California legal system acknowledges that these injustices can occur and provides avenues for compensation.

Under the California Penal Code Section 4900, individuals who have been wrongfully imprisoned for crimes they did not commit may be eligible to sue the state for damages. However, proving wrongful imprisonment requires showing that the conviction was overturned based on new evidence or a lack of legal grounds for detention.

Can You Sue the State for Wrongful Imprisonment in California?

Specific legal criteria must be met to sue the state for wrongful imprisonment successfully. In California, a claim can be filed under the California Victim Compensation Board (CalVCB) if:

• The conviction was reversed or dismissed based on new evidence or a violation of constitutional rights.
• The claimant did not contribute to their wrongful conviction through false confessions or other misleading actions.
• The claimant can prove their innocence with clear and convincing evidence.

A civil lawsuit can also be pursued under California’s Government Claims Act, allowing individuals to seek compensation for civil rights violations.

The Process of Filing a Lawsuit for Wrongful Imprisonment Against the California State

Filing a claim for wrongful imprisonment in California involves several steps:

1. Obtain Proof of Exoneration – Before initiating a lawsuit, you must gather official documents proving your conviction was overturned by the court, usually due to new evidence or legal errors.
2. File a Claim with CalVCB – You must submit a compensation claim to the California Victim Compensation Board within two years of your exoneration date to be eligible.
3. Submit Evidence of Wrongful Conviction – Present strong supporting documentation such as DNA testing results, court transcripts, or recanted witness statements to establish the wrongful nature of the conviction.
4. Attend Hearings and Legal Proceedings – You may need to participate in a hearing or provide testimony as a panel or judge reviews your claim for verification.
5. Pursue a Civil Rights Lawsuit (if applicable) – If your case involved misconduct by authorities, you can file a federal civil rights lawsuit to pursue additional financial compensation for the harm caused.

This process can be complex, making legal representation crucial to securing the best possible outcome.

Damages You Can Recover in a Wrongful Imprisonment Lawsuit Against the California State

Victims of wrongful imprisonment may be entitled to significant compensation, which can include:

• Statutory Compensation – Under California Penal Code 4904, exonerees can receive $140 per day of wrongful incarceration.
• Lost Wages and Future Earnings – Compensation for lost income due to the time spent imprisoned.
• Pain and Suffering – Monetary damages for the emotional and psychological trauma endured.
• Legal Expenses – Reimbursement for attorney fees and other litigation costs.
• Punitive Damages (in civil lawsuits) – Additional compensation may be awarded if misconduct played a role in the conviction.

Each case is unique, so consulting a knowledgeable attorney is vital to maximizing compensation.

Why Hiring a Lawyer is Crucial for Suing the State for Wrongful Imprisonment

Suing the state for wrongful imprisonment is complex and requires substantial legal expertise. An experienced attorney can:

• Gather and present evidence to prove innocence and damages.
• Navigate California’s legal procedures and ensure compliance with deadlines.
• Negotiate settlements or litigate aggressively in court.
• Advocate for full compensation under all applicable laws.

Ready to Take the Next Step Toward Justice?

You deserve to be heard and your rights restored if a wrongful conviction has harmed you. Pointer and Buelna, LLP – Lawyers For The People will fight with you to hold the state accountable and to ensure you get the justice you deserve. Get your clean slate today. Contact us for a free consultation at (510) 929-5400, and let our experienced wrongful conviction lawyers in California assist you through every aspect of your case.