Blog

March 10, 2025

Police Settlement Payouts by State: What You Need to Know in California

Written by Pointer & Buelna, LLP. Lawyers For The People, reviewed by Adanté Pointer

Police brutality settlements are a significant issue affecting communities nationwide. These payouts often result from police misconduct cases, including excessive force, wrongful arrests, and civil rights violations. Police settlement payouts by state vary widely due to differences in state laws, local policies, and the prevalence of police misconduct. At Pointer and Buelna, LLP – Lawyers For The People, we are committed to helping victims of police brutality seek justice and secure fair compensation.

Key Factors Influencing Police Settlement Amounts

Several factors influence the amount of a police misconduct settlement:

• Severity of Misconduct: Cases involving excessive force or deadly encounters tend to result in higher settlement amounts.
• Strength of Evidence: Video footage, credible eyewitness testimony, or official reports can significantly increase the likelihood of a favorable settlement.
• Jurisdiction: Settlements vary based on state laws and local policies. Larger cities often pay higher amounts due to greater public scrutiny and larger budgets.
• Officer’s Disciplinary Record: If the involved officer has a history of misconduct, it can lead to larger settlements and increased public attention.
• Legal Representation: An experienced legal team, such as Pointer and Buelna, LLP—Lawyers For The People, can make a crucial difference in ensuring victims receive their rightful compensation.

Notable Police Settlement Cases Across the U.S.

California

California has seen some of the largest police misconduct settlements. In 2020, Edward Bronstein’s family received a $24 million settlement after his fatal encounter with the California Highway Patrol. Additionally, Jamal Trulove, wrongfully convicted of murder, was awarded $13.1 million by the city of San Francisco. These cases highlight systemic issues in law enforcement and the ongoing need for reform.

New York

New York City has paid billions in police misconduct settlements. One of the most well-known cases involved Eric Garner, who died in 2014 after an NYPD officer placed him in a chokehold. His family received a $5.9 million settlement in 2015, igniting nationwide protests and calls for increased police accountability.

Colorado

Colorado has also faced high-profile police brutality cases. The family of Elijah McClain, a 23-year-old who died after a violent arrest by Aurora police in 2019, received a $15 million settlement. In addition to the payout, the case led to commitments for policing reforms to prevent future incidents of misconduct.

New Mexico

New Mexico has one of the highest rates of police brutality cases per capita in the U.S. Reports indicate that systemic issues in law enforcement have led to millions of dollars in settlements annually. 

The Financial Impact of Police Settlement Payouts on States

Police brutality settlements are costly and often funded by taxpayers. According to The Trace, in the past decade, 25 of the largest police departments in the U.S. paid out over $3.2 billion in misconduct settlements.

Additionally, data from the Police Funding Database shows that some of the largest police misconduct settlements exceed tens of millions of dollars, further highlighting the financial consequences of inadequate police oversight.

Take Action: Know Your Rights and Pursue Justice

If you or a loved one has been a victim of police misconduct, taking immediate legal action is crucial. Pointer and Buelna, LLP – Lawyers For The People is dedicated to fighting for justice in police brutality and civil rights cases. Contact us today for a consultation.