Blog

May 28, 2025

Who Polices the Police?

Written by Pointer & Buelna, LLP. Lawyers For The People, reviewed by Adanté Pointer

Public trust in law enforcement has come under increased scrutiny as unsettling incidents of police misconduct continue to surface across the nation. This situation raises a critical question: Who polices the police? The mechanisms for ensuring accountability are complex, often requiring a combination of oversight agencies, legal recourse, and community efforts. If you’re in California, understanding these systems is crucial for protecting your rights and holding law enforcement accountable.

At Pointer and Buelna, LLP – Lawyers For The People , our mission is to assist those affected by police misconduct in seeking justice. If you wonder how accountability works or how you can fight for your rights, this guide breaks it down with clear and actionable information.

Oversight in Action: Who Polices the Police in California?

California has layers of oversight to address police misconduct. At the state level, independent oversight bodies like the California Department of Justice conduct investigations into officer-involved shootings of unarmed civilians. Additionally, the Commission on Peace Officer Standards and Training (POST) is critical in certifying and decertifying officers based on their conduct.

On the local level, police departments often establish internal affairs divisions to investigate complaints lodged against their officers. However, internal investigations frequently face criticism for lacking impartiality, prompting the rise of citizen oversight committees in some municipalities. These committees provide an additional layer of transparency by representing community perspectives.

While these measures offer some accountability, they are far from flawless. Misconduct can still go unchecked due to system loopholes, prompting the need for more independent alternatives.

Independent Investigative Agencies: Are They Truly Impartial?

The effectiveness of independent investigative agencies (IIAs) largely depends on their independence from law enforcement structures. A hallmark of successful oversight is maintaining impartiality, which includes proper funding mechanisms and investigators without police backgrounds. By ensuring their operations are not influenced by law enforcement culture, IIAs like Ontario’s Special Investigations Unit in Canada provide valuable models for fair oversight.

California has made strides in this area with Assembly Bill 1506, which enables the State Department of Justice to conduct investigations into police shootings involving unarmed civilians. However, challenges like limited staffing and insufficient funding may hinder the timely execution of investigations.

For IIAs to be truly effective, they must avoid bias, focus on high-stakes cases, and maintain transparency in their findings. This is critical to restoring public confidence in law enforcement.

Legal Recourse for Victims of Police Brutality

For individuals who experience police misconduct, pursuing legal recourse is essential in seeking justice and accountability. Victims can file civil lawsuits under state or federal law to obtain compensation for damages such as emotional distress, medical expenses, or loss of income caused by police actions. California has also enacted legislative measures to further hold law enforcement accountable.

One significant step is SB 2 , also known as the decertification law. This law prevents officers guilty of serious misconduct, such as excessive force, dishonesty, or racial bias, from continuing their careers in law enforcement by publicly decertifying them and barring them from transferring to other agencies.

Additionally, SB 2 improves transparency by requiring law enforcement agencies to report officer misconduct records to a centralized database. According to the PPIC , this database dismantles long-standing barriers that previously allowed abusive officers to evade accountability and shields their behavior from public scrutiny.

Victims of police brutality can also seek assistance from attorneys who specialize in civil rights and police misconduct cases. These legal professionals help victims file claims, gather vital evidence such as footage or witness statements, and navigate the often-complex legal processes of holding law enforcement officers and agencies accountable.

Challenges in Holding Police Accountable

Despite oversight measures, holding police accountable remains an uphill battle. Systemic issues such as lack of transparency, legislative hurdles, and challenges securing funding for investigative bodies often complicate efforts to address misconduct effectively.

Laws like AB 1506 mandate the California Department of Justice to investigate specific incidents of police misconduct. However, as reported by CalMatters , these investigations are frequently delayed due to understaffing and resource constraints. Additionally, determining the outcome of such investigations can take years, leaving victims and their families in prolonged uncertainty.

Another pressing issue is the role of police unions, which often resist accountability reforms. Unions may lobby against legislative changes or negotiate contracts that protect officers from repercussions. This systemic resistance underscores the need for continued advocacy and reform.

How a Police Brutality Lawyer Can Help You Fight for Justice

• Legal assistance is a treasured tool for victims of police brutality who seek to be brought to account. A skilled lawyer can aid:
• Collect evidence, including video recordings, police statements, and witness accounts.
• Identify illegality, such as abuse of force or unjust detention.
• Advise victims to appear in written complaints, mediation, or court.
• Encourage fair recompense for physical, emotional, and economic injury.

At Pointer and Buelna, LLP—Lawyers For The People , we have extensive experience with police misconduct cases. Our lawyers are knowledgeable about California’s evolving accountability laws and committed to securing our clients’ justice.

Speak with a Police Brutality Lawyer in California Today

If you or a loved one has been impacted by police misconduct, the law is on your side. At Pointer and Buelna, LLP – Lawyers For The People , we’re here to help you fight for justice and seek the truth. Contact our team today at (510) 929-5400 for a free consultation. We can hold law enforcement accountable and ensure your rights are fully protected.